THE POLEMIC OF FEMALE DEACONS: CONTROVERSIAL PERSPECTIVES IN THE ORTHODOX CHURCH
The Rev. Tom Soroka, left, and John Maddex co-host an episode of "Ancient Faith Today Live" titled "The OrthodoxDeaconess: Examining the Call for Restoration" on Jan. 30, 2024. (Video screen grab)
February 5, 2024,
A recent episode on Ancient Faith Radio regarding the revival of female deacons has sparked intense debate within the Orthodox Church community. The discussion, initiated by a symposium sponsored by the St. Phoebe Center for the Deaconess, has ignited passionate opinions from both supporters and opponents of the idea.
During the broadcast, various perspectives were presented, ranging from enthusiastic support to staunch opposition. However, instead of fostering constructive dialogue, the programme seemed to deepen existing divides within the Orthodox Church.
Critics of the idea expressed concerns about the potential implications of reintroducing female deacons, with some invoking historical biases and questioning the necessity of such a move. Metropolitan Saba, a prominent figure in the Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America, raised doubts about the timing of the discussion, suggesting it might be influenced by secular feminist movements rather than genuine pastoral needs.
Supporters of the female diaconate argued passionately for its reinstatement, citing the potential benefits of addressing issues specific to women within the church community. They emphasised the importance of providing pastoral care tailored to the unique experiences of women, such as sexual abuse and trauma.
However, the programme failed to bridge the gap between opposing viewpoints. Accusations of bias and dismissal were levelled from both sides, further fueling tensions. Additionally, controversial remarks made by some participants, such as comparing the deaconess movement to a slippery slope towards female priesthood, only served to inflame the discourse.
The aftermath of the broadcast revealed deep-seated divisions within the Orthodox Church regarding the role of women in ministry. Advocates for the female diaconate expressed disappointment in the lack of support and understanding from church leadership, while opponents remained steadfast in their opposition.
As the Orthodox Church grapples with these contentious issues, the debate over female deacons continues to highlight broader questions about gender roles and theological interpretation within the faith community. Despite the discord, many hope that continued dialogue and reflection will ultimately lead to a more inclusive and equitable church environment.
News Sources : https://religionnews.com/2024/02/05/orthodox-christian-radio-hosted-a-broadcast-on-deaconesses-then-misogyny-poured-in/
What's Your Reaction?
